"Know then thyself, presume not God to scan, The proper study of mankind is Man."‘ (Epistle II of Pope’s "Essay on Man") : Presenting Man's Position in the Universal Scheme of Things


"Know then thyself, presume not God to scan,
The proper study of mankind is Man."

These two lines constitute the beginning of ‘Epistle II' of Pope’s Essay on Man, his most didactic poem written in the antithetical mode and presenting man's position in the universal scheme of things.

Alexander Pope
 The lines begin with an inversion. The inverted second half of the antithetical declare that man should not presume to scan or judge Gods ways. This is in fact, as Wilson Knight calls in The Vital Flame, “a reflection from Milton”. If Milton had proposed to “justify the ways of god to man” (Epistle: I). ‘Vindicate’ is a less patronizing and more referential attitude and expression. Like Milton, Pope emphasizes not only the weaknesses of man is general; but emphasizes the weakness of pride in particular. 

Man would, in his pride, have the pretension of examining and judging God’s ways. Pope, on the other hand, has one single and profound impulse – to submit to the world in which he found himself and to stifle the promptings of pride which would suggest that is the world and not man which is out of joint.

The first half of the anti – thesis there fore declares the desirable alternative: Know then themselves’. This is an age old dictum found in Juvenal and ascribed to the Greek God Apollo. Indeed, the phrase gnothi seauton (Words of Pythagoras) or “Know thyself” which was inscribed on the temple of Apollo in Delphi, finds its parallels in both Latin and Sanskrit scriptures. If "know than thyself’ points to an introspective study, the next line, ‘They proper study of Mankind is Man’ points to the external, the study of fellow human beings. It is noteworthy that Pope finds everyman to be the epitome of all human kind. This is because the bed rock of humanity – consisting of the most Vital and fundamental qualities – is the same for all human beings. Man’s difference from man lies, not in the essentials but in the in the incidentals. Thus the first two lines present Pope’s philosophical opinion regarding man needing to examine himself, since the examination would reveal that the cause of human sorrow lies not in God but himself.

In a Nutshell:
  • Alexander Pope's "Essay on Man" is a philosophical work that explores the nature of humanity and the role of God in the universe.
  • The essay argues that human beings are imperfect and fallible, but that they are also capable of reason and self-improvement.
  • Pope suggests that human beings can learn from their mistakes and strive to improve themselves, but that ultimately they are subject to the laws of nature and the will of God.
  • The essay also argues that there is a hierarchy in the universe, with humans occupying a central position between the angels and the animals.
  • Pope's "Essay on Man" has been widely debated and discussed, with some critics arguing that it is too optimistic and others claiming that it is too pessimistic.
  • The poetic essay remains an important work of philosophy, offering insights into the human condition and our place in the universe.

Comments

Recent Posts

Popular posts from this blog

Dr. Samuel Johnson's "Preface to Shakespeare": Points to Remember

Dr. West’s New Method of Teaching English :Its Merits and Demerits

Milton's Use of Epic Simile in "Paradise Lost", Book-I